April 2004 WSJ Article: Gifted Education

FROM:
Terry James Mohaupt, Chairman, Parent Affiliates
ILLINOIS ASSOCIATION FOR GIFTED CHILDREN
an affiliate of National Association for Gifted Children

The following article should inspire discussions in your groups and districts.

Boosting Minorities In Gifted Programs Poses Dilemmas; Nontraditional Criteria Lift Admissions of Blacks, Poor; Fear of Diluting Programs; New Focus on the Very Top
Wall Street Journal
Print Media Edition:      Eastern edition
New York, N.Y.
Apr 7, 2004

Author:                  Daniel Golden
----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Abstract:

Every Tuesday, the fifth-grader at Greenview Elementary attends a three-hour
advanced class in which she studies algebra and researches topics such as the
history of hot-air balloons. "The 'challenge' class helps me get ahead," says
11-year-old TiShanna, an African-American from a single-parent family, who was
identified as gifted by a special test intended to boost minorities. "When my
older brother comes home, I help him with his homework."

Under this system, minority children often qualify only on the basis of
nonverbal scores, officials say. "Some people say they're weaker students," says
Jane Snyder, gifted-education coordinator for Greenville County. "I say, 'Weak
in what way?' Obviously, they're strong in mathematical skills."

School-board members say the gifted center will lure prosperous families to the
area who might otherwise be skeptical of Greenville's schools. "No matter how
many Ph.D.'s you bring here, we can handle your kids," says board member William
Herlong, a lawyer. He dismisses the weekly "pull out" program for TiShanna Smith
and other gifted students as "not highly challenging."

Copyright (c) 2004, Dow Jones & Company Inc. Reproduced with permission
of copyright owner....
----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Full Text:

GREENVILLE, S.C. -- Under South Carolina's old rules, TiShanna Smith
wouldn't be considered gifted. Under its new rules, she is.

Every Tuesday, the fifth-grader at Greenview Elementary attends a three-hour
advanced class in which she studies algebra and researches topics such
as the history of hot-air balloons. "The 'challenge' class helps me get
ahead," says 11-year-old TiShanna, an African-American from a single-parent
family, who was identified as gifted by a special test intended to boost
minorities. "When my older brother comes home, I help him with his
homework."

Around the country and especially in the South, new tests are propelling
more minority students into predominantly white gifted- education programs.
Proponents applaud what they say is an overdue easing of racial disparities
in gifted education, stressing that the special classes can open greater
opportunities for blacks, Hispanics and Native Americans.

But it's not that simple. By changing the standards for gifted education,
traditionalists say, school districts seeking classroom equity are undermining
academic excellence. Some minority students identified as gifted are actually
struggling in regular classes, raising questions about whether the new criteria
accurately gauge academic ability. And some school-board members, teachers and
parents complain that the admission of more students, both white and minority,
has watered down the quality of gifted programs. In response, a number of school
districts, including Greenville County, have created super- gifted programs that
are almost entirely white.

"If too large a percentage of your students are placed in a gifted category,
you're not dealing with the best and the brightest," says Tommie Reece,
chairwoman of the Greenville County school board. "You're diluting the program."

Gifted programs emerged nationwide in the 1970s to give talented
elementary-school students extra challenges. In some areas, the programs were
promoted by white parents trying to circumvent court- ordered racial
desegregation. Districts typically identified students as gifted who scored in
the top 5% -- 130 or above -- on traditional intelligence tests measuring verbal
and math skills. Whites tend to outscore minorities on these tests, which made
gifted programs overwhelmingly white.

Gifted students typically are excused from regular classes for part or all of
the day for accelerated instruction, sometimes including museum trips and other
enrichment activities. They often have a leg up on entry into honors and
advanced-placement tracks in middle and high school.

In the mid-1990s, the Clinton administration began pushing to desegregate gifted
education, particularly in the South. Civil-rights officials reviewed states and
districts with the largest racial disparities in gifted education, questioning
their reliance on traditional intelligence tests. South Carolina, Alabama,
Tennessee and many individual districts reached agreements with the government
to adjust their standards. Other states and districts adapted without federal
action.

In these states, students can qualify as gifted with top scores on traditional
tests. But if they don't, they can make the grade by doing well on alternative
tests. The newer tests are designed to identify gifted minority and low-income
white children whose language skills lag because of deficiencies in early
schooling or home environment.

Some of the alternative tests don't use words at all. Elementary- school
students, for instance, might be required to detect patterns of geometric
shapes. Others let students manipulate tangible objects, such as letter tiles.
Research shows minority children tend to score higher on these tests than on
traditional ones.

In Alabama, students who fall just short on these alternative tests may still
qualify by getting credit for leadership, motivation or creativity. High
grade-point averages are also now more widely used as a basis for admitting
students to gifted classes. But an "A" in a low- achieving, inner-city school
counts as much as an "A" in an affluent suburban school with a tougher
curriculum.

In Alabama and Georgia, black students in gifted programs have more than doubled
since the late 1990s. Georgia now counts 15,880 gifted black students, or 15% of
its gifted population, up from 5,813, or 9%, in 1996. Blacks make up 38% of all
Georgia schoolchildren. The number of gifted black students in Alabama last year
rose to 4,480, or 15% of the gifted population, up from 1,637, or 8.6%, in 1998.
That is still well short of the 36.4% black share of all students in Alabama.

In North Carolina, the number of black students identified as gifted rose 21%,
to 8,777, in 2002-03, up from 7,251 in 1998-99. Chattanooga, Tenn., has 166
gifted African-American students, up from 62 in 1998- 99.

White students have taken advantage of the new opportunities as well, though at
a slower rate of increase. In Charleston, S.C., the number of black students
identified as gifted has more than tripled to 1,100, or 4.7% of all black
students, from 333 in 1998-99, or 1.3%. Over the same period, the number of
gifted whites more than doubled, to 4,907, or 28.6% of all white students, up
from 2,086, or 12.7%. The proportion of Charleston students considered gifted
has grown from 5.8% to 14.6% of total enrollment.

This growth has strained class size in some gifted programs. To limit expansion
and make sure that minority students become better represented, a few
jurisdictions have set lower standards only for nonwhites.

Florida maintained a separate track into gifted programs for minority and
low-income students until 2002, when it eliminated the racial preference in
response to lawsuits by white students denied gifted status. Following the rule
change, black participation in gifted education in Florida fell slightly in the
fall of 2003.

In Charleston, W.Va., most white students take a traditional intelligence test,
but most minority, as well as some low-income white students, are given a
nontraditional test. Cut-off scores vary too. Whites must score 127 or above
overall, while "historically underrepresented groups" -- black, low-income and
disabled students -- need only 120 on any of three sections of the
nontraditional test, along with strong grades and achievement scores. The number
of black gifted students has nearly tripled to 38 this year from 14 in 1998-99.

In Tennessee, teachers refer students for evaluation for gifted programs based
on 16 characteristics, including being "at risk for environmental, cultural or
economic factors." Students may be admitted based on school grades and awards,
nonverbal tests or creativity.

Franklin, Tenn., reacted to the establishment of the new guidelines four years
ago by creating a special, district-wide class for "profoundly gifted" students
with intelligence quotients of 145 or above. Almost all of the students were
white. Franklin later eliminated the I.Q. requirement out of concern that the
reliance on just one criterion violated state regulations.

Gifted-education officials in South Carolina say some teachers complain that
some students who qualify as gifted are faltering in their regular classes.
These students may fall further behind when they are pulled out of regular
classes for special offerings, the officials say.

Prof. Joyce VanTassel-Baska of the College of William and Mary in Williamsburg,
Va., who co-developed South Carolina's new test, found in a recent follow-up
study that a "significant minority" of students identified as gifted by that
test are soon placed on academic probation from the gifted program -- with the
threat of removal if their regular grades don't improve.

"I went nuts when I heard that," says Prof. VanTassel-Baska. "What good does it
do to find kids who look very promising and then, because it takes them a while
to adjust, put them on probation?" In response to her study, the state is
standardizing guidelines for removing students from gifted programs.

The same study found that gifted third- through seventh-graders identified by
the test Prof. VanTassel Baska helped develop are often weak in verbal and
organizational skills. But it also concluded, based on state test scores for
2002-03, that these students improve their verbal scores during their second
year in gifted programs and in math surpass students identified by traditional
tests.

South Carolina students are automatically eligible for gifted programs if they
score in the top 4% overall on a traditional test designed to measure aptitude.
Otherwise, they can qualify with high scores on either the verbal or math
sections of an aptitude test (which is similar to an intelligence exam) and an
achievement test. If they reach those heights in aptitude or achievement, but
not both, they have to pass either the verbal or math sections of the test Prof.
VanTassel-Baska helped design.

Under this system, minority children often qualify only on the basis of
nonverbal scores, officials say. "Some people say they're weaker students," says
Jane Snyder, gifted-education coordinator for Greenville County. "I say, 'Weak
in what way?' Obviously, they're strong in mathematical skills."

Greenville has attracted foreign employers such as a BMW plant but has pockets
of poverty left by the closing of textile mills. Although district enrollment is
28% African-American, for decades its gifted program was almost exclusively
white.

"You could go on any day into a gifted program, it was quite obvious that it was
an all-white program," says Leola Robinson, one of two black members of the
Greenville school board. "I've had white teachers tell me they began to get
grief from white families if they admitted some students of color into the
program."

Aided by the new test, Greenville has nearly doubled the number of black gifted
students, to 606 last year, or 7.6% of gifted students, up from 320 in
1999-2000. Gifted white students have increased 43.3%, to 7,027 last year, from
4,904 in 1999-2000.

Greenville has also tailored its gifted curriculum to students who have
difficulty reading by emphasizing hands-on lessons. In math, third- through
fifth-graders simplify algebraic equations by removing number cubes and chess
pawns -- which stand for the unknown X -- from either side of a scale. Once they
have mastered this approach, it is easier for them to make the leap to abstract
equations and working on paper.

In a temporary classroom at Greenview Elementary, where 87.2% of students have
household incomes at or below the poverty line, gifted- education teacher Anne
Stockman recently gave the verbal section of the test Prof. VanTassel-Baska
helped develop to nine second- and third-graders, including six
African-Americans and one Hispanic student. Eight-year-old Sequoia Brown, who is
African-American, said she wants to join the program "so I can be smarter" and
become a doctor or veterinarian.

Unlike an administrator of a traditional test, Ms. Stockman didn't offer just
brief instructions. Instead, she helped the students practice the types of items
they will encounter on the test.

On an overhead projector, Ms. Stockman jotted down a word problem similar to one
the students were about to encounter. Hands flew up, and she identified correct
answers. Then, armed with scratch paper and letter tiles, students had 15
minutes to do the task individually on the test.

The new approach has made a difference at Greenview. The school's 19 gifted
students include 10 African-Americans and one Hispanic, up from only two
minority students out of seven in the gifted program in 2000. Seven of the 11
gifted minorities at Greenview, including TiShanna Smith, were identified
through nontraditional means -- either the alternative test or school grades.

TiShanna qualified by acing a math-achievement test and the math portion of the
alternative test. TiShanna, who will take high-level math and English courses
next year in middle school and says she wants to become a pediatrician, says the
gifted class has whetted her appetite: "I'd like to go all week long," instead
of for three hours.

Some Greenville students are now fulfilling that dream, but almost all are
white. In prior years, all gifted students in the county left their regular
classes for only a few hours of special attention each week in their own school
buildings. This year, the district established a full-time center for "highly
gifted" third graders: the top 2% based on traditional aptitude and achievement
tests. The center will add a grade each year until it serves third- through
eighth- graders. Although cutbacks in state aid have strapped the district
financially -- it eliminated 229 teaching positions this year -- it gave a
laptop computer to every student at the center. On Tuesdays after school, a
volunteer from Mensa, the society of people with high I.Q.'s, offers magic
lessons.

School-board members say the gifted center will lure prosperous families to the
area who might otherwise be skeptical of Greenville's schools. "No matter how
many Ph.D.'s you bring here, we can handle your kids," says board member William
Herlong, a lawyer. He dismisses the weekly "pull out" program for TiShanna Smith
and other gifted students as "not highly challenging."

Susan Simmons transferred her third-grader, Stephen, to the center after hearing
the same message about the pull-out program. "I talked to three of the gifted
teachers, and they told me they had seen a real change in the ability level of
the children," she says. "They said it wasn't a real challenge class, just
mildly accelerated."

Of 64 students at the gifted center this year, 59 are white, three
Asian-American, one biracial, and one African-American. None came from Greenview
Elementary.

Of 108 invitees for next year, four are black, according to Ms. Snyder, the
gifted-education coordinator.

Carmen Harris, an assistant professor of African-American history at the
University of South Carolina at Spartanburg and the mother of the biracial
student in the program, says the district should do more to inform minority
parents about how their children can qualify for the gifted center.

"At this age, what my daughter is getting educationally and socially is good,"
Prof. Harris says. "But there are issues I have to worry about for my child that
white parents don't. I am concerned about first-love relationships as she
approaches her teen years. I wonder if there will be a boy there who will want
to date her. I'm also concerned about the long-term effect of being in a mostly
white culture on her ability to interact with nonwhites."

Mr. Herlong says the board won't adjust standards to admit more minorities to
the center. "We're not here to socially re-engineer," he says.

---

Question of the Day: Should schools alter selection criteria for gifted
programs to ensure more minorities are included? Visit WSJ.com/Question
to vote.

Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner.
....

=============================== End of Document
GOALS:
1 - Increase the networking opportunities for parents of 165,000+ students throughout 889 school districts in Illinois
2 - Assist all parents with ways to advocate for their children.

e-mail tmohaupt@chicago.us.mensa.org
See gifted information at the following sites:
* Crystal Lake Friends of Gifted Education http://www.crystallakenet.org
* Downers Grove FRoG: Friends of the Gifted and Talented http://www.dgfrog.org/
* Mt. Prospect/Chicagoland SAGE: Supporters and Advocates of Gifted Education http://mtprospect.org/sage/
* Rockford Gifted program: http://www.rps205.com/departments/gifted/
* Rockford Parents for Gifted Education: http://www.PGE205.org
* Schaumburg Friends of the Gifted (FOG) http://www.elkgrove.org/fog54
* Regional: http://www.chicago.us.mensa.org/kids/parents.htm
* State: http://www.iagcgifted.org
* National: http://www.nagc.org
* World: http://www.worldgifted.org/
* Hoagies' Gifted Education Page   http://www.hoagiesgifted.org
* Hoagies' Kids and Teens Page     http://www.hoagieskids.org
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The contents of this document are copyright ©2004 by Illinois Association for Gifted Children (IAGC) and are intended only for use by members for the purposes of organizational and personal correspondence. Reproduction or use by non-members, and use by members for commercial purposes are expressly forbidden. We respect your right to privacy. By providing your name, e-mail address, and other information, you are giving IAGC permission to contact you. IAGC will take reasonable care to protect your privacy. You agree to release IAGC from any liability for any reason. If you do not agree to these terms, please e-mail tmohaupt@chicago.us.mensa.org and copy & paste these words in the subject field: "Please remove me from your list." Comprehensive virus prevention, detection, and elimination are provided by Norton Internet Security®.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"Rarely do we find men who willingly engage in hard, solid thinking.
There is an almost universal quest for easy answers and half-baked solutions."
--The Reverend Martin Luther King, Jr.